On Thursday, S.C. House Rep.Gilda Cobb-Hunter, D-Orangeburg, hosted a community education forum on artificial intelligence and data center development at the Orangeburg-Calhoun Technical College.
Orangeburg residents were invited to submit questions ahead of time about their concerns, uncertainties and confusion surrounding data centers, an industry playing a growing role in South Carolina. Just this month, Spartanburg's county council approved three data center development agreements of varying size, with council passing another three on first reading.
Orangeburg County Council passed a one-year data center moratorium in September. Cobb-Hunter and the panelists say they are still researching the industry extensively and encourage the public to educate themselves as local officials consider its future in the county.
Many residents asked questions regarding how data centers use water, and what the impact would be to taxpayers.
Panelist Charles Snow, the director of Tribal Partnerships at data center developer, Strata Expanse, says data center water usage depends on how its cooling systems are designed.
According to Snow, data centers use water to cool computer chips. This can happen in three different ways: air-based cooling, evaporative cooling, or closed-loop liquid cooling.
Snow says data centers using large amounts of water have evaporative cooling systems.
“That's where the water is just going through, getting the heat from the chip. It's coming out and then it's evaporating into the atmosphere," he said.
He says closed-loop liquid cooling systems work by re-circulating cooling fluid through a contained system, ultimately minimizing water requirements.
"You have that water, that liquid in an enclosed system that's not evaporating, and it's going through the chips, getting that heat and then bringing it back outside. [You] can get extremely efficient with that," Snow says.
Warren Harley, the General Manager of the City of Orangeburg’s Department of Public Utilities, says DPU has safeguards to ensure large customers, like a data center, do not negatively impact its system or other customers. He says the DPU re-evaluated how they conduct businesses, after Bitcoin miners came into the city, with high-energy-use groups.
"When we talk about data centers, if you're talking about a hyperscale—100 megawatt, 500 megawatt—we can't entertain those. They're out of our ability and beyond our resources to serve. [What] is more suitable for our community are things in the 25 to 50 megawatt range," Harley says.
Harley says DPU have updated their contracts dealing with projects like data centers, to ensure the city isn't stuck with stranded costs. Stranded costs happen when a utility invests money to serve a customer and that customer doesn't show up to realize the benefit. He says whatever the cost to serve a data center might be, the developer will cover the "full freight” of everything.
Those upfront payments cover the cost of connecting a data center, but not the ongoing upkeep of the system. Harley says that maintenance is “recovered in the rate that you pay,” just as it is for other customers. DPU charges industrial customers and residents “to cover the cost that they create on the system,” he says. That includes a reasonable profit the utility can reinvest in the system to serve customers, “whether it’s a data center or anybody else.”
Orangeburg resident Michael Lett says he learned more at the forum than on his own. "Everybody's wanting to understand, what is it going to cost them? [And] I think the board and everybody did a tremendous job tonight, just giving us the information."
Cobb-Hunter says the forum does not suggest the city or county's position on the topic of data centers. "The only thing that has been determined, from my perspective, is that it's important that you educate yourself about this issue. It's important that you look at all sides of this issue."